Dave Mustaine Says David Ellefson's Megadeth Exit Was Likely Near Before Leak

Megadeth frontman Dave Mustaine revealed in an excerpt from his memoir "In My Darkest Hour" that the departure of bassist David Ellefson was already imminent before the May 2021 video leak. The excerpt, published by Rolling Stone on September 10, 2023, details how internal discussions about Ellefson's future had begun months earlier. Mustaine explained, "We were already talking about moving on, even before the video surfaced," indicating that the band had been evaluating lineup changes well before the scandal erupted. The leaked footage, which showed Ellefson masturbating in a private setting, sparked a wave of online speculation and media coverage. Within days, the band announced Ellefson's dismissal on May 24, 2021, citing "inappropriate behavior" that conflicted with the group's values. Mustaine's memoir confirms that the incident accelerated a decision already under consideration. He added, "The video made the conversation louder, but the conclusion was already there." According to the memoir, the band had been experiencing tension over creative direction and touring commitments during the early months of 2021. Ellefson, a founding member since 1983, had expressed concerns about the demanding schedule, while Mustaine was focused on finalizing the "The Sick, the Dying... and the Dead!" album, slated for release in September 2022. The internal deliberations involved management, legal counsel, and the remaining members, who were weighing the impact on the band's brand and fan base. Rolling Stone notes that Mustaine's account includes direct quotes from internal emails and meetings. One email excerpt reads, "We need to decide if we can continue with David given the current climate," reflecting the seriousness of the situation. Mustaine also recalled a private meeting on April 15, 2021, where the band discussed potential replacements, though no name was finalized at that time. The revelation adds nuance to the public narrative that the leak was the sole catalyst for Ellefson's exit. It underscores the complex dynamics within Megadeth and highlights how personal conduct and professional disagreements can intersect in high‑profile bands. Fans and industry observers now have a clearer picture of the timeline leading to the bassist's departure, which ultimately reshaped the group's lineup for subsequent tours and recordings. Ellefson later issued a public apology and pursued legal action to address defamation claims, while Megadeth continued with a series of guest bassists before officially appointing James LoMenzo as a permanent member in 2022. The episode remains a pivotal moment in the band's history, illustrating both the fragility of long‑standing relationships and the resilience of Megadeth's brand.

Dave Mustaine discussing Ellefson's exit